State of Proof

The case docket

Proof Dockets

One record per claim: the exact statement, locked source, evidence collected, scope limits, provenance, and most important open step.

No headline claim is presented as settled.

Active examinations

Claims with an examination route underway.

2026-08-23-alpoge-s6 · Complex geometry

A completed (3,4,∞) modular family gives a compact complex threefold diffeomorphic to S⁶

The 108-page manuscript claims that a completed (3,4,∞) family of complex two-tori produces a compact complex threefold diffeomorphic to S⁶. Exact finite identities and a stipulated local torsion mechanism have been reproduced locally. Analytic quotient and gluing, relative meridian signs, integral homology, and the headline theorem remain unresolved.

Record state
Active examination
Source
retrieved 2026-08-24 · locked
Next open step
Trace the relative meridian signs and toric zero-section independently before reusing the passing group arithmetic

2026-07-29-maxwell-conjecture · Potential theory

Five positive point charges in R³ have at least 24 nondegenerate critical points, contradicting the proposed (5−1)² bound

The manuscript claims five positive charges yield at least 24 nondegenerate critical points. A local exact-algebra check reproduces the displayed limiting polynomial's classification of 21 real, nondegenerate critical points, conditional on manual transcription. The polynomial's derivation from the charge potential, 24-point persistence, Morse perturbation, global finiteness, and the counterexample remain unresolved.

Record state
Active examination
Source
arXiv v1 · locked
Next open step
Independently derive the displayed limiting polynomial from the five-charge potential, including the exact Taylor coefficients and analytic remainder

Queued records

Claims mapped for a future examination.

2026-02-14-openai-first-proof · Proof evaluation

Ten independent First Proof attempts form a calibration corpus; attempt 2 is the first blinded examination target

This case is not one theorem and will not receive a corpus-wide pass or fail. The locked packet contains ten independent proposed solutions. Attempt 2 is the first blinded negative-control target; OpenAI's public assessment is held out until the lab's status and evidence are frozen.

Record state
Queued record
Source
revised packet · locked
Next open step
Freeze the blinded attempt-2 working bundle and version-delta record without leaking the known external comparator label

2025-10-27-nesterov-point-convergence · Optimization

The stated Nesterov accelerated-gradient iterates converge to a minimizer for every L-smooth convex objective with a minimizer

The locked v2 manuscript claims point convergence of the Nesterov iterates, not merely convergence of objective values. Four load-bearing gates are mapped from the recurrence and energy inequality through the unique-cluster-point argument. No gate has run.

Record state
Queued record
Source
arXiv v2 · locked
Next open step
Independently derive the recurrence equivalence and discrete energy inequality under the exact tₖ hypotheses

2026-07-10-openai-cycle-double-cover · Graph theory

Every finite bridgeless undirected graph has a cycle double cover

The three-page manuscript claims the cycle double cover conjecture and ships with a public Lean artifact. Both sources are locked. The first gate is prose-to-Lean statement and definition correspondence; the repository has not been built or mathematically examined in this lab.

Record state
Queued record
Source
PDF + Lean 577e9d9 · locked
Next open step
Map the manuscript's theorem and graph conventions to the pinned Lean endpoint before drawing any inference from a build

2026-08-01-openai-nonsofic-group · Group theory

The unit group of the binary Leavitt algebra L_F₂(1,2) is not sofic

Chapter 3 of OpenAI's updated Ten Advances manuscript claims that the binary Leavitt algebra's unit group is not sofic. The pinned Lean commit predates a substantive prose revision by four days. Paper-to-Lean and version correspondence is therefore the first gate; no build or mathematical examination has run.

Record state
Queued record
Source
updated 2026-08-06 · locked
Next open step
Reconcile the substantively revised August 6 prose with the August 2 Lean commit before any formal replay is treated as relevant

Statuses are records of evidence collected for a defined scope. They are not peer-review decisions, publication recommendations, or certificates of mathematical truth.

Full docket JSON · State Changes Atom feed